Can Undersea Volcanoes Cause Global Warming?
It’s well known that active volcanoes on land can cause significant global cooling when they erupt, from shielding of sunlight by sulfate aerosol particles in the eruption plume which linger in the atmosphere. But what is the effect on climate of undersea volcanic eruptions such as the massive submarine blast that blanketed the nearby South Pacific kingdom of Tonga with ash in January?
Submarine volcanoes are relatively unexplored but are thought to number over a million, of which several thousand may be currently active. Many lie along tectonic plate boundaries, where plates are pulling apart or colliding with each other. The Tonga volcano sits above a geological pileup, where the western edge of the Pacific plate dives under the Indian–Australian plate.
The eruption of any volcano releases a huge amount of energy. In the case of a submarine volcano that may be thousands of meters deep, the plume may not even reach the surface and all the energy is absorbed by the ocean. The Tonga eruption was from a shallow depth, so much of the energy was dissipated at the ocean surface – launching a destructive tsunami – and in the atmosphere – generating a plume of ash that reached a record altitude of 55 kilometers (34 miles), a shockwave that traveled around the globe, and nearly 400,000 lightning strikes.
You might think all that energy could contribute to global warming, had the volcano erupted in deeper water that would have converted all the energy to heat. However, the oceans, which cover 71% of the earth’s surface, are vast and can hold 1,000 times more heat than the atmosphere. Any change in sea surface temperatures from even multiple underwater volcanic eruptions would be imperceptible.
This can be seen from a simple calculation. According to NASA scientists, the energy released by the undersea Tonga eruption was equivalent to the explosive power of 3.6 to 16 megatonnes (4 to 18 megatons) of TNT. For comparison, the 1980 eruption on land of Mount Saint Helens in Washington state released about 22 megatonnes of TNT equivalent, and the famous 1883 explosion of Indonesia's Krakatoa unleashed 180 megatonnes; the atomic bomb that the U.S. dropped on Hiroshima in Japan in 1945 released roughly 14 kilotonnes of TNT equivalent.
The upper Tonga limit of 16 megatonnes is equal to 7.5 x 1016 Joules of energy. Assuming the heat capacity of seawater to be 3,900 Joules per kilogram per degree Celsius and the total mass of the oceans to be 1.4 × 1021 kilograms, it would take 5.5 × 1024 Joules (5.5 trillion trillion Joules) to warm the entire ocean by 1 degree Celsius (1.8 degrees Fahrenheit).
So if all 16 megatonnes had gone into the ocean, ocean temperatures would have risen by (7.5 x 1016)/( 5.5 × 1024) or a minuscule 1.4 x 10-8 (14 billionths) of a degree Celsius. The Krakatoa above-water eruption, on the other hand, decreased global air temperatures by as much as 1.2 degrees Celsius (2.2 degrees Fahrenheit) for several years and may have cooled the oceans as well.
But there’s another potential source of warming from submarine volcanoes, and that is the CO2 emitted along with the sulfur dioxide (SO2) that causes cooling through formation of sulfate aerosols. If the underwater plume reaches the ocean surface, both gases are released into the atmosphere. In the case of Tonga, while the amount of SO2 emitted was too small to have any cooling effect, the emitted CO2 could in theory contribute to global warming.
However, the yearly average of CO2 emissions from all volcanoes, both on land and submarine, is only 1 to 2% of current human emissions that have raised global temperatures by 1 degree Celsius (1.8 degrees Fahrenheit) at most. So any CO2 warming effect from an underwater eruption is unlikely to be much larger than the above calculation for energy release. Interestingly though, Chinese researchers recently reported that the atmospheric concentration of CO2 near Tonga after the eruption jumped by 2 parts per million, which is as much as the global concentration normally increases in a whole year from human sources. But this is most probably a temporary local effect that won’t affect the global CO2 increase expected in 2022.
Despite the inability of undersea eruptions to affect our present climate, it was suggested in a 2015 research paper that CO2 from submarine volcanoes may have triggered the warming that pulled the earth out of the last ice age about 15,000 years ago.
The basic idea is that lower sea levels during glaciation relieved the hydrostatic pressure on submarine volcanoes that suppressed eruptions during warmer times. This caused them to erupt more. After a lengthy ice age, the buildup of CO2 from undersea eruptions initiated warming that then began to melt the ice sheets covering volcanoes on land, causing them in turn to belch CO2 that enhanced the warming, melting more ice in a feedback effect.
Next: New Projections of Sea Level Rise Are Overblown